Table of Contents
Home @ Roofscape

About Roofscape
@ Play

Bikeways
Beans About Boston
Bird N-E-W-S
Book Bag
Cityscape

Cookout
Coop Confidential
Funk Shui
Garden Gates
Garden Girl TV

Garden Journal
Greenways
Kid'scape
Landscapes
Outerwear
Outside Office
Paths to the Past
Radio Roofscape
Roofscape News
Roofscape Realty
Roofscape Views
Rooftop Movie Night

Screenscape
Siteseeing
Skyscape
Soundscape
Starscape
Streetscape
Street Scene
Thought for the Week
Urban Myths
Wild Lives


Dr. King in Boston

Stephen Bastide

This article is a currently a work in progress. Comments: roofscape@gmail.com.

 

In early September 1951 Martin Luther King, Jr., ML as his father called him, packed his bachelor belongings into a shiny new green Chevrolet and headed north for the thousand mile drive to Boston. The Chevy, equipped with the recently introduced Powerglide automatic transmission that he'd admired in a friend's car, was a gift from Daddy King as his father, Reverend Martin Luther King, Sr., was often called by his family and flock. It was his reward for graduating at the top of his class in May from Crozer Theological Seminary outside Philadelphia.

1951 was a key year of transition for the country. The final business of World War II was winding down and, bridged by the futile Korean War, the Cold War was heating up.

It was the year of Duck and Cover. Atomic testing and war games began in the Nevada desert and Marshall Islands. The first nuclear power plant went into operation. The Rosenbergs were tried and executed for slipping A-bomb secrets to the Russians.

The first commercial computer, Univac 1, went into service and next year predicted the presidential election. The transistor was developed at Bell Labs. Coast-to-coast direct phone dialing and TV broadcasts began.

Upon his arrival from the Jim Crow South, King soon encountered the harsh reality of the segregated North.

I remember very well trying to find a place to live. I went into place after place where there were signs that rooms were for rent. They were for rent until they found out I was a Negro, and suddenly they had just been rented. 1

After some searching he and Phillip Lenud, a friend from Morehouse College where King did his undergraduate work, found an apartment at 397 Massachusetts Avenue in the South End across from the Savoy Cafe. The Savoy has long since ceased stomping (replaced by an apartment building at 400 Mass. Ave.), but King's digs still stand, a few doors down from the Orange Line T station and marked with a small bronze plaque.



397 Massachusetts Avenue, Boston.

The South End was the center of black middle class life and culture throughout the first half of the 20th century, beginning after 1900 when African Americans moved there from their historic home on the backside, or black-side, of Beacon Hill behind the State House. By 1950, they also shared the densely populated neighborhood with 39 other ethnic groups, many of them recent immigrants to the country: Syrian, Lebanese, Armenian and Chinese.

Martin might have preferred to be closer to campus but racial prejudice prevailed, as we've seen, and he chose a place just over the tracks of the northeast rail lines, on the very dividing line between black and white Boston. This block at the corner of Mass. and Columbus Avenues anchored one of America's great jazz meccas, home to over a dozen different clubs offering every sort of America's own music. Two blocks away, in the white Back Bay, Symphony Hall and the conservatories programmed and studied European classical music.

Boston had always been, and in the postwar years still was, racially segregated, as was most of the country. Unlike the South, segregation wasn't on the books or legislated, but the de facto lines were clearly drawn in black and white and well understood by both races. Blacks weren't allowed to live in most neighborhoods, stay in hotels, eat at restaurants, work in many jobs, sometimes simply walk the streets and most of all mingle with whites.

The one area where these racial rules were relaxed was on this dividing line in the South End where the jazz clubs catered to both races. Here blacks and whites, audiences and musicians, freely met, mingled, dug the music, jammed and romanced.

The black South End was refulgent with style. The jazz musicians and dancers were fashion plates and their patrons followed suit. There were numerous barber shops and beauty parlors. The Pullmen porters wore immaculate uniforms. And after syling on Saturday night, a snappy Sunday Best was the required dress to attend any of the neighborhood's churches, as numerous as the clubs.

Martin fit right in, always stepping out on the street in a tailored suit, often tweed, with a white shirt, crisply knotted tie, fedora, shined shoes, briefcase and meticulously groomed with a thin mustache and close cropped hair.

He'd been a sharp dresser, a dandy even, since grade school when his friends - Shag, Rooster, Sack and Mole among them - nicknamed him Tweedie for the tweed suits he favored wearing to school (often with a violin under his arm) and church. But he pulled it off with such panache that he never suffered ridicule for his finery and slipped easily into Levis for playing football in the backyard with his crew.



Tire Jumping. Allan Rohan Crite.

Martin also worked to develop the affectations befitting an intellectual, smoking and gesturing with a pipe as a constant prop, like other many students. His long love of big words and flowery, ornate phrases also peaked in, and mercifully moderated after, graduate school. He practiced flourishing signatures on the back of notebooks to embellish the important documents he would soon be signing. A distant philosophical gaze, as glimpsed years later in the photograph at the top of this article, and a detached, reserved manner of speaking completed the picture of a worldly urban intellectual of the times grasping with the big questions.

Boston University was, and is, one of the country's largest private universities. It was founded as a theological school in 1839, at the Bromfield Street Church in downtown Boston by abolitionist Methodist ministers, to provide equal, integrated education for both races and sexes, a very unusual stance at that time and for long thereafter. Bromfield was also the church of David Walker, the fiery black abolitionist activist and author of the radical 1829 Appeal to the Colored Citizens of the World advocating immediate, worldwide black emancipation via violent insurrection and killing if necessary.

At B.U., King exchanged the cozy, collegial atmosphere of Crozer, a small seminary in a quiet suburb, for the anonymous hustle and bustle of a big urban research university in a major American city. Among the tens of thousands enrolled at B.U. were two dozen or so black graduate students. King and Lenud started an informal club for them soon after setting up house, the Dialectical Society, open to anyone interested philosophical and/or theological ideas and issues.

Dialectics is a logical conversation, ranging from informal dialogue to formal debate, between two or more people wanting to convince the other(s) of their positions, with perhaps the possibility of achieving a synthesis of the their various viewpoints. This was the method popularized by Plato's Socratic Dialogues and used throughout the history of philosophy.

Martin believed that this struggle, rather than dogma, was essential to religion. As a teenager he'd developed deep doubts about the fundamentalism of his father, but religion he began to think is only alive at the edges. It may be important to have the courage of one's convictions, but it's also essential to have the courage of one's doubts.

July 23, 1954 - Boston

Darling,

... I am doing quite well, and studying hard as usual. I have plenty of privacy here and nobody to bother me.

We had our Philosophy Club Monday night and it was well attended. Brother Satterwhite did the paper. ...

Your Darling,
Martin

Letter to Coretta at the Dexter Avenue church pasonage written while Martin was away on one of his regular trips back in Boston to work on his doctoral thesis.

The Philosophy Club gathered one evening a week in King's living room for fellowship, food and conversation "to solve the problems of the world." A dozen or so black students, men and women, shared a potluck supper, sipped coffee and chatted. One of the members would present a formal paper that they'd written for one of their classes. Then pipe smoke and lofty technical jargon swirled together in the air as the others jumped in to oppose or defend the writer's conclusions. Afterwards, with the dialectics done, the night owls remaining would settle into a late night bull session.

The club lasted throughout Martin's three student years in Boston, growing in popularity and eventually attracting both white students and local college professors. Professor DeWolf himself, Martin's thesis advisor, dropped in once and read the paper for discussion on "the meaning of the kingdom and how it will come."

Martin had explained his choice of Boston University (not his first, but Yale Divinity School had rejected him despite being at the top of his class at Crozer) this way in his application to the School of Theology.

For a number of years I have been desirous of teaching in a college or a school of religion. Realizing the necessity for scholastic attainment in the teaching profession, I feel that graduate work would give me a better grasp of my field. At present I have a general knowledge of my field, but I have not done the adequate research to meet the scholarly issues with which I will be confronted in thie area. It is my candid opinion that the teaching of theology should be as scientific, as thorough, and as realistic as any other discipline. In a word, scholarship is my goal. For this reason I am desirous of doing graduate work. I feel that a few years of intensified study in a graduate school will give me a thorough grasp of knowledge in my field.

My particular interest in Boston University can be summed up in two statements. First my thinking in philosophical areas has been greatly influenced by some of the faculty members there, particularly Dr. Brightman. For this reason I have longed for the possibility of studying under him. Secondly, one of my present professors is a graduate of Boston University, and his great influence over me has turned my eyes toward his former school. From him I have gotten some valuable information about Boston University, and I have been convinced that there are definite advantages there for me. 2

Edgar S. Brightman was an influential philosopher and Christian theologian who had many followers among the Crozer faculty including King's adviser at the seminary. For decades while teaching at B.U., from 1919 to 1953, Brightman was a leader of the theological movement called Personalism or more particularly since he, B.U. and other Boston intellectuals were such a force in the development and spread of this school of thought, Boston Personalism.

Personalism posits that the person is central, both the starting and end point, for understanding the world, indeed the universe. It believes that all moral truth begins with the absolute value of the person, the sacredness of the individual's being, consciousness and personality. Personalism is a philosophy which, applied to theology as it is in the Boston school, strongly affirms the existence and importance of the soul in each human and sentient being and reaffirms the existence and essense of God in a rather complex, nuanced and unique relationship with each person. It also is quite critical of impersonalistic theories and thought - social Darwinism, Communism, etc. Martin explained Personalism this way.

I studied philosophy and theology at Boston University under Edgar S. Brightman and L. Harold DeWolf. ... It was mainly under these teachers that I studied Personalistic philosophy - the theory that the clue to the meaning of ultimate reality is found in personality. This personal idealism remains today my basic philosophical position. Personalism's insistence that only personality - finite and infinite - is ultimately real strengthened me in two convictions: it gave me metaphysical and philosophical grounding for the idea of a personal God, and it gave me a metaphysical basis for the dignity and worth of all human personality. 3

A key to understanding King is that he was a philosopher, by far the most important of the 20th century, a philosopher who shook society to its core and changed the world. Dr. King's was professionaly trained, over many years, in philosophy. As a child he was immersed in the Baptist fundamentalism of his father's church. But in his teens he developed deep doubts and began studying philosophy as an undergraduate at Morehouse College, then continued at Crozer, University of Pennsylvania, Boston University and Harvard. His life and actions were animated by a deep love, understanding and use of philosophy. King's six books mention many philosophers and philosophical concepts. In fact his first book, Stride Toward Freedom (1958) sites 18 different philosophers just in telling the story of the 381 day Montgomery Bus Boycott sparked by Rosa Parks. 4

Personally, meanwhile, King was waging a concerted campaign to marry. Having decided upon a career in the ministry as a Baptist pastor, at least temporarily, he needed to get married. In the black church of the time, and even today, an unmarried pastor was unacceptable. Marriage was a must. The pastor's wife was considered a pillar of the church and a gurantee of the pastor's stability and good character. Ministry without marriage, and marriage without children, was unheard of.

Imperious Daddy King, intent on ML joining him after graduation and eventually succeeding him at Ebenezer, had been forcefully pressing the marriage issue for some time. His plan had been to match Martin with a suitable member of elite Negro society in Atlanta, but the many attempts had all gone awry.

King, although often in conflict with his father, felt a deep connection with his family. He frequently called home, collect, to chat for two or three hours, mostly with his mother, describing every detail of his days - including his dates. The pressure was on to find a wife, both from within and without.

Coretta Scott King - in a 2003 telephone interview with a Boston Globe reporter - described meeting an eager Martin - over the phone - after her number was slipped to him by a mutual friend.

Coretta Scott. Antioch College class photo.

 The truth is, Martin and I met on the telephone.

He said, 'I like the way you talk, and I'd like to meet you.' We agreed to meet for lunch the next day at Sharaf's on Massachusetts Avenue, and he said, 'I usually make it in 10 minutes, but tomorrow, I'll make it in 7.'

On our first date he deliberately asked a question that had to do with capitalism versus communism. ... I remember I made an intelligent comment, and he said, 'Oh, I see you know something other than music.' I thought, of course I did. I was a graduate of Antioch College. I had thoughts of my own.

He said, You know, you have everything I ever wanted in a wife: intelligence, beauty, character, and personality. When can I see you again? I said I really didn't know because I had a tight schedule.

... he ways always trying to convince me I was it ... but I kept struggling with my own ambitions for a long time. I knew getting married would lead me away from performing and the direction I'd hoped to go.

We got married in 1953, and the rest is history. When I finally opened myself up to the relationship, I knew this was my direction. 5

After the newlywed Kings returned to Boston in the fall of 1953 and got settled in again, Martin resumed talks with his thesis advisor, L. Harold DeWolf, about the Ph.D. dissertation that he would write in 1954, at the end of the current academic year.

Dr. King leading the April 23, 1965 March on Boston.

Dr, King revisited his old neighborhood in the spring of 1965 and brought along tens of thousands of friends as witnesses. Marching had become one of his major political methods, as described in an invitational letter to the April 23 March on Boston.

In August of 1963 the citizens of this country marched on Washington, 200,000 strong, demanding freedom and justice for all our citizens. Last month Americans marched from Selma to Montgomery demanding that Alabama free its Negro citizens from the bondage in which they are held. Dr. Martin Luther King was at the front of both of those marches.

The focus of the march was the deplorable state of the Boston schools which served, or rather mis-served, African American students. Substandard housing and unemployment in the black community were also concerns.

On Friday, April 23 [1965], Dr. King will come to Boston. He is calling upon the citizens of Massachusetts and New England to join with him in placing before the political and economic leaders of this state the need for immediate action in the fields of education, housing, and jobs. The Negroes of Massachusetts have had to accept bad schools, slum housing, and inadequate job opportunities for all too long.

 

Editor's note ... We're going to jump ahead here - for now - to deal with the difficult issue of plagiarism in Dr. King's thesis and other works.

In 1990 the editor of Dr. King's papers, Clayborne Carson, very reluctantly confirmed the shocking fact that large parts of King's Ph.D. dissertation - and his other student papers - were in fact plagiarized. The New York Times reported it this way.

"We found that there was a pattern of appropriation, of textual appropriation," said the 46-year-old historian, who was active in the civil rights movement and has written extensively on black history. He spoke at a news conference at Stanford, called after an article in The Wall Street Journal yesterday disclosed details of the project's findings. "By the strictest definition of plagiarism -- that is, any appropriation of words or ideas -- there are instances of plagiarism in these papers."

Although he said that he believed Dr. King had acted unintentionally, Mr. Carson said that Dr. King had been sufficiently well acquainted with academic principles and procedures to have understood the need for extensive footnotes, and he was at a loss to explain why Dr. King had not used them.

Mr. Carson and other scholars who have seen the papers declined to say how great a percentage of the material had been plagiarized, but they said it was enough to indicate a serious violation of academic principles. 6

Dr. King's plagiarism is almost impossible to understand, difficult to accept and both diminishes and doesn't dim his stature. Facts are stubborn things. We have to face the fact that careful scholarship over five years by a team of trained researchers, headed by a noted historian hand-picked by Coretta Scott King in 1985, uncovered a pattern of plagiarism in his nearly 400 page thesis and other student works. And this finding, hidden for over 30 years, opens up other very troubling questions - what about his speeches, books and sermons? What about I Have a Dream?

Editor's note ... The following four paragraphs of text will appear at the end of this article,

Dr. Martin Luther King's time in Boston had a profound influence on him. Malcom X's life and work was forged in Boston. Here, Martin pursued his doctoral studies in Christian theology at Boston University. Malcolm learned to read and created his own education while imprisoned for burglary in Charlestown and other state prisons. Both sons of Baptists ministers preached and ministered here, Martin in Baptist churches, Malcolm at Nation of Islam temples.

Both left to blaze on the world stage, but both repeatedly returned back to Boston and acknowledged the inluence the city had had upon them. Martin arrived in Boston in the fall of 1951 to enroll at B.U. for graduate studies just as Malcolm was finishing his intense prison self-education, receiving parole in 1952.

Martin, born on January 15, 1929, would be 81 this year. Malcolm, born May 19, 1929, would be 85. Both could be alive today and serving as important American elder statesmen of the stature of Nelson Mandela in South Africa, who's 92 this year. But both lives were brutally cut short by assasins bullets, Martin in 1965 at age 39 and Malcolm in 1965 at 40.

We'll look at Malcolm's troubled times in The Hub beginning with the May 15 issue of Roofscape in the companion article X in Boston.

 

Timeline of Dr. Martin Luther King's time in Boston and related events.

January 15, 1929 Martin Luther King, Jr. born in Atlanta, Georgia.
Fall 1943 King enters Morehouse College, age 15.
Fall 1948 King enters Crozier Theological Seminary in Chester, Pennsylvania.
September 1951 Martin Luther King, Jr. moves to Boston.
September 13, 1951 King enters the Boston University School of Theology.
January 1, 1952 Martin is introduced to Coretta by a fellow student at the New England Conservatory of Music.
February 25, 1952 Kings academic advisor at B.U., theologian Edgar S. Brightman (born 1884), dies. L. Harold DeWolf becomes his new advisor.
June 18, 1953 Martin and Coretta marry at Scott's home near Marion, Alabama with his father, the Reverend Martin Luther King, Sr., presiding. They live at the King residence in Atlanta for the rest of the summer.
Fall 1953 The Kings return to Boston, renting a new apartment in the South End. He resumes discussions with Dr. DeWolf about his Ph.D. dissertation.
January 25, 1954 King delivers a trial sermon, The Three Dimensions of a Complete Life, at the Dexter Avenue Baptists Church in Montgomery, Alabama. Soon after he is offered the position as their new pastor.
April 14, 1954 King accepts the Dexter pastorate.
May 2, 1954 King delivers his first sermon at the Dexter Avenue Baptist Church.
May 17, 1954 Brown v. Board of Education. The U.S. Supreme Court rules that segregation in public schools is unconstitutional.
June 5, 1955 King receives his doctorate from Boston University.
December 1, 1955 Rosa Parks arrested in Montgomery, Alabama for refusing to move to the back of the bus, sparking the 381 day Montgomery bus boycot.
December 5, 1955 Montgomery Bus Boycot begins.
   
   
 
   
   
   
   
   

 

References

1. King quoted in the Boston Globe, April 25, 1965.
2. The Martin Luther King, Jr. Research and Education Institute
3. Personalism. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
4. Martin Luther King's Personalism and Non-violence. Warren E. Steinkraus.
5. Mrs. King and I, on when she met Martin. Cara Feinberg. Boston Globe, 2/5/06.

 

 

Image ... Dr. Martin Luther King. Courtesy of MLK Online.